Short answer
A migraine is a specific headache disorder, not just a bad headache. Under ICHD-3, migraine attacks last 4 to 72 hours, are often one-sided and throbbing, get worse with routine activity and come with nausea or light and sound sensitivity. Tension-type headache is usually two-sided and pressing. Cluster headache is short, severe and around one eye.
Key takeaways
- Migraine is one headache disorder with its own diagnostic criteria (ICHD-3), not simply a stronger headache.
- Duration is a big clue: about 4 to 72 hours for migraine, 30 minutes to 7 days for tension-type, 15 to 180 minutes for cluster attacks.
- Nausea, or sensitivity to both light and sound, points toward migraine; one-sided eye watering and restlessness point toward cluster headache.
- The same person can have more than one type, so only a clinician can say which one you have.
- A sudden, extremely painful headache, or one with weakness, speech or vision problems, needs emergency care.
What is the difference between a migraine and a headache?
A headache is a symptom. Migraine is one specific headache disorder with its own definition. The International Classification of Headache Disorders (ICHD-3) describes migraine as attacks lasting 4 to 72 hours that are typically one-sided, pulsating, moderate or severe, made worse by routine activity, and joined by nausea or by sensitivity to light and sound 1.
The American Migraine Foundation goes further: migraine is more than a headache. It is a neurological disease that comes in many forms, both with and without head pain 7.
Other headache disorders follow different patterns. The two most often confused with migraine are tension-type headache and cluster headache.
Migraine vs tension headache vs cluster headache: comparison table
This table summarizes how ICHD-3 and the NHS describe each type in adults. Real attacks vary, and not every attack fits one column neatly.
| Migraine (without aura) | Tension-type headache | Cluster headache | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Typical pain | Pulsating, moderate or severe, worse with routine activity such as walking or climbing stairs 1 | Pressing or tightening, mild to moderate, not worse with routine activity 2 | Severe or very severe 3; sharp, burning or piercing 6 |
| Location | Often one side; usually front and temple area 1 | Usually both sides 2; head, face or neck 5 | Strictly one side: around or above the eye, or the temple 3 |
| Duration | 4 to 72 hours, untreated or not treated successfully 1 | 30 minutes to 7 days 2 | 15 to 180 minutes, untreated 3 |
| How often | Varies; some people have attacks several times a week, others less often 4 | Frequent type: 1 to 14 days a month 2 | From once every other day up to 8 times a day, in bouts lasting weeks or months 3 |
| Accompanying symptoms | Nausea or vomiting, or sensitivity to both light and sound; some people have aura 1 | No nausea or vomiting; at most one of light or sound sensitivity 2 | Same-side red or watering eye, blocked or runny nose, eyelid swelling, facial sweating, small pupil or drooping eyelid, restlessness 3 |
In children and teenagers, ICHD-3 notes that migraine attacks may last 2 to 72 hours and are more often on both sides of the head than in adults 1.
How do doctors define a migraine?
Doctors use the ICHD-3 criteria. For migraine without aura, a person needs at least five attacks that each last 4 to 72 hours, have at least two of four pain features, come with nausea or vomiting or with both light and sound sensitivity, and are not better explained by another diagnosis 1.
The four pain features are:
- one-sided location
- pulsating quality
- moderate or severe intensity
- made worse by, or causing you to avoid, routine physical activity
Someone who fits these criteria but has had fewer than five attacks is classed as having “probable migraine” 1.
Some attacks include an aura: temporary visual, sensory or speech symptoms. ICHD-3 states that each aura symptom usually lasts 5 to 60 minutes 8. About a quarter of people with migraine experience aura, according to the American Migraine Foundation 7. Aura is one of the four phases of a migraine attack.
What does a tension-type headache feel like?
A tension-type headache usually feels like pressure or tightness on both sides of the head. ICHD-3 describes it as mild to moderate, not throbbing, and not made worse by walking or climbing stairs. It comes without nausea or vomiting, and with at most one of light or sound sensitivity 2.
The NHS adds that the area may feel tender, and that you should be able to carry on with daily activities without making the headache worse 5.
The two types can live side by side. ICHD-3 notes that frequent tension-type headache often coexists with migraine without aura. It says both should be identified, preferably with a diagnostic headache diary, because their treatments differ considerably 2.
What does a cluster headache feel like?
A cluster headache is an attack of severe, one-sided pain around or above the eye or at the temple. ICHD-3 says attacks last 15 to 180 minutes when untreated and come from once every other day to eight times a day. They come with eye, nose or face symptoms on the same side, or with restlessness 3.
The pattern is distinctive:
- Attacks come in series, called cluster periods, that last weeks or months, separated by pain-free periods that usually last months or years 3.
- About 10 to 15% of people have a chronic form without those pain-free periods 3.
- People are usually unable to lie down and often pace the floor 3.
- Attacks may come at the same time of year or at set times of day 6.
ICHD-3 notes that onset is usually between ages 20 and 40 and that men are affected about three times as often as women 3. The NHS points out that cluster headaches are rare, and that some of their symptoms can be the same as migraine 6.
Can you tell which type of headache you have by yourself?
No. Knowing the patterns helps you notice what happens and describe it well, but it is not a diagnosis. The last ICHD-3 criterion for migraine is that the attacks are “not better accounted for by another ICHD-3 diagnosis” 1. Ruling other causes out is a clinician’s job.
The sources give several reasons:
- One or a few migraine attacks can be hard to tell apart from migraine-like attacks with another cause. That is why ICHD-3 asks for at least five 1.
- One person can have more than one headache type 2.
- There is no specific test for cluster headache. A GP asks about the pain, where it is and how often it comes, and may refer you for a brain scan to rule out other causes 6.
- The NHS says a throbbing pain at the front or on one side, feeling sick, or finding light or noise painful can be signs of a different type of headache than tension-type, such as migraine or cluster headache, and are a reason to see a GP 5.
The American Migraine Foundation notes that pinpointing the exact cause of head pain can be difficult. It suggests keeping a record of all your symptoms and bringing it to your doctor 7.
What should you write down to help your doctor tell them apart?
Write down the details that separate the types in the table above: how long each attack lasts, where it hurts, what the pain feels like and what came with it. The NHS lists how often, how long, how painful, other symptoms, possible causes and medicines taken as the details a GP may ask for 5.
- Start and end time. Duration is one of the clearest differences between the three types 1 2 3.
- Where it hurts. One side, both sides, or around one eye. A headache location chart can help you describe it.
- What the pain feels like and how strong it is. Throbbing, pressing, sharp or burning, and a number on a pain scale.
- Whether moving made it worse. Walking or climbing stairs is the example ICHD-3 uses 1.
- Other symptoms. Nausea, light or sound sensitivity, aura, a watering eye, a runny nose or restlessness.
- Timing. Time of day, and whether attacks come in groups.
- Medicines taken and whether they helped.
If you are taking painkillers often, mention it. The NHS notes that taking painkillers for headaches too often or for a long time can itself cause headaches 5. Read more about medication overuse headache, and talk to your doctor before changing any medicine.
Our guide on how to keep a headache diary covers the habit in more detail. You can use a printable headache diary template, or Migraine Diary, our iPhone app, which saves the start and end time in one tap and lets you add pain level, location and symptoms afterwards.
When is a headache an emergency?
Some headaches need emergency care, whatever type you think they are. On its migraine page, the NHS says to call emergency services if you 4:
- have a headache that came on suddenly and is extremely painful
- have problems speaking or remembering things
- lose your vision, or have blurred or double vision
- feel drowsy or confused
- have a seizure or fit
- have a very high temperature and symptoms of meningitis
- cannot move, or have weakness in, the arms or legs on one side of the body or one side of the face
- have recently had a head injury
For cluster headache, the NHS advises emergency care if an eyelid droops, or one pupil becomes smaller than the other, for the first time 6. The American Migraine Foundation advises seeking medical attention immediately for any weakness with a headache 7.
In the US, call 911. The NHS also advises not to drive yourself to the emergency department 4.